
If you are what you eat, then it follows that you are what you eat eats, right?
The debate over whether grass-fed or grain-fed beef is superior is somewhat misleading, because in most cases, cattle consume both grass and grain. After weaning, beef cattle are typically raised on pasture for the first several months of their lives and then often transition to a diet supplemented with grain. The real debate is over whether beef cattle should be fed primarily—or even exclusively—grass, or whether grain should be introduced toward the end of their lives.
For most of history, since the domestication of animals, beef cattle were raised exclusively on grass/forage. Once it was discovered that feeding cattle grain during the last few months of their lives increased yield, many ranchers began supplementing their diets with grain.
Beef advertised as “grass-fed” grew more appealing as Americans became more concerned about animal welfare, the environment, and their total fat intake. Despite the fact that the term “grass-fed” can mean different things depending on whom you ask, and the Agricultural Marketing Service actually dropped its official definition of the term in 2016, many associate the label with healthier cows that produce beef lower in fat. For years, fat reigned as the primary culprit of obesity in the United States, so some meat-eaters looked to grass-fed beef as a healthy alternative. But now we know that fat is not black and white, and in reality, some types of fatty acids are actually beneficial to our health. Here’s a brief look at the pros and cons of grass-finished and grain-finished beef:
Grass-Finished Beef
Pros
- Leaner: One of the primary draws of grass-finished beef is that it is typically leaner, with a higher proportion of “good fats” such as omega-3 fatty acids and conjugated linoleic acid. For anyone who is trying to limit their total fat intake, grass-fed beef has an understandable allure—grain-finished beef has been shown to be 2-4 grams higher in total fat per 100 grams than grass-fed beef, as consumed.
- Distinct flavor: Another potential benefit is that grass-finished beef tends to have a distinct flavor from grain-finished beef, due to the difference in fat content and any lingering flavors from grazing. This can be either a pro or a con, depending on your palate. People raised on grass-fed beef unsurprisingly often prefer grass-fed beef.
Cons
- Can have a gamey flavor: The gamey flavor can potentially be off-putting for fans of grain-finished beef.
- More expensive: Grass-finished beef produces lower yields, which means it will likely cost more per pound. Farmers also typically need more time to fatten grass-fed cattle to slaughter weight, which means more costs passed on to the consumer.
- Lower fat content: Grass-finished beef’s lower overall fat content also means less “good fat.” (Monounsaturated fats have been shown to help lower cholesterol, prevent coronary disease, and aid with weight loss. And even saturated fats have been shown to have health benefits).
What This Means for Wagyu
Wagyu are typically raised on pasture for the first several months of life, and they continue to have some forage in their diet in feedlots as well. Wagyu raised exclusively on grass/forage is rare, however, because the beef is prized for its marbling and wealth of good fats, and those qualities are enhanced by the introduction of grain toward the end of life.
Grain-Finished Beef
Pros
- Higher fat content: Depending on whom you ask, grain-finished beef’s higher fat content is actually a good thing. More fat means more beneficial fatty acids and increased marbling, which means more rich flavors in the beef. Because beef is a primary source of monounsaturated fats in the U.S., grain-finished beef could be considered healthier in that aspect, with U.S. grass-finished cattle producing beef with 30-70 percent less monounsaturated fatty acid (MUFA), compared to beef from grain-finished cattle.
- Can be more tender: Related to its higher fat content, grain-finished beef is often reported to be more tender than grass-finished beef.
- Has a “beefier” taste: Again, it depends on culture and personal preference, but Americans often prefer grain-finished beef and associate it with a traditional, “beefy” taste.
Cons
- Higher in overall fat content: If you’re worried about fat content, you might prefer grass-fed beef, but in the end, the difference isn’t enormous.
- Perceived as less healthy for the cattle by some: Some argue that rapidly fattening up cattle with grain toward the end of their lives is less healthy than a more natural diet of all grass and forage.
What This Means for Wagyu
Wagyu cattle are typically finished with grain in order to increase fat content and accentuate the natural marbling of the beef. Cattle receive the benefits of grass/forage for the majority of their lives and have the added nutrients of grain at the end.
If you’re looking to try Wagyu beef raised on some of the finest grasses and grains, look no further.